Feeling particularly ballsy? Start with ten fish instead of five, then pose questions that require a higher wager. To do so, you need enough goldfish to pay out losses: If there are four other players (five total), you’d need to put 12 tokens on the line to ask a three-goldfish zinger about Mike’s shoes that you’re sure no one knows - but be careful, as it needs to be something that someone will *think* they know, or you'll pay the price. In goldfish.