@RoundTheRoom said:

I have no problem with the fans voting in the Tahoe Tweezer as #1, because the fan voting is incredibly biased in the Twitter age (it's so easy for casual fans to have heard the Tahoe Tweezer and not, say, the Orlando Stash, etc.).

That said, wow the Tahoe Tweezer is overrated here. Would not make my top 26 jams. I do think it's great, but Phish has '93-'00 of heavy touring in their prime to contend with. I could find 26 better jams in '94-'98, without too much trouble. Ymmv.

This is pretty much spot on imo except for the part of the Tahoe tweezer being great. it is good in my book but that's as far as I would go. Otherwise Im with ya roundtheroom