Great article. I enjoyed reading that this morning. I actually like to focus on the differences in order to experience both bands in my own way. The Dead and Phish seem so different each time I think about it and listen to them. That author's use of the idea of cycles is right on in my book. Right now, I am churning through Phish shows, mainly the all-star shows of 97-98 because it has been a little while and I am just simply on that kick. But I know, once the leaves start changing a little and a nip hits the air, I will be digging deep into some 70's Dead that has been on the back burner. I really go on benders with these two. Musically, Trey explains it well with his interview with Charlie Rose. The Dead is Americana. They channeled Bill Monroe, the old blues singers, and 1950's roots music long before members of Phish were born. Their music is twisted Americana 1960's style. When Phish started making music, they could pick from all that as well, but were also able to interpret the interpretations of that music. Zep, Zappa, Hendrix, The Dead themselves, and mainstream classic rock is intertwined deeply in Phish songs and jams.

Personally, for thick funk, intensity, musical composition (waxbanks is pretty right on with his article concerning chaos), and actual experience, I enjoy Phish. When the band is locked in to a building Antelope jam and rides the wave of the crowd, I feel that energy. But for pure emotion, song writing, lyrics, and undeniable magnetism, I go for the Dead. Jerry's vocal delivery on China Doll from Reckoning and the band's tender support is so organically emotional, that I get chills every time. And Bobby fans are people, too! Great discussion and nicely written article.